Recurring jobs with single method having different parameters

bug?
1

I am using Hangfire Recurringjob api to scedule some jobs but I am using same method with different arguements. For ex
for SelectAll(int scenario){};
RecurringJob.AddOrUpdate(SelectAll(1));
RecurringJob.AddOrUpdate(SelectAll(2));

Here the recurring job is getting overridden instead adding both jobs with different scenario .
Please help me how can it solve my use case.

2

Hi @sachin_kumar!

When you use this overload of RecurringJob.AddOrUpdate method Hangfire generate recurring job id by type and method name:

public class SomeType 
{
    public void SelectAll(int i) { ... }
}

...

RecurringJob.AddOrUpdate(SelectAll(1));
// recurringJobId = "SomeType.SelectAll"

Thus RecurringJob.AddOrUpdate(SelectAll(1)) create new “SomeType.SelectAll” recurring job, but RecurringJob.AddOrUpdate(SelectAll(2)) override it.

You should use another overload of RecurringJob.AddOrUpdate with recurringJobId parameter to create both jobs:

RecurringJob.AddOrUpdate("SelectAll 1", SelectAll(1));
RecurringJob.AddOrUpdate("SelectAll 2", SelectAll(2));